Challenge to the model of lake charr evolution: Shallow- and deep-water morphs exist within a small postglacial lake

Louise Chavarie; Andrew M. Muir; Mara S. Zimmerman; Shauna M. Baillie; Michael J. Hansen; Nancy A. Nate; Daniel L. Yule; Trevor Middel; Paul Bentzen; Charles C. Krueger

doi:10.1111/bij.12913

USGS · 70178481

Challenge to the model of lake charr evolution: Shallow- and deep-water morphs exist within a small postglacial lake

Louise Chavarie·Andrew M. Muir·Mara S. Zimmerman·Shauna M. Baillie·Michael J. Hansen·Nancy A. Nate·Daniel L. Yule·Trevor Middel·Paul Bentzen·Charles C. Krueger

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

All examples of lake charr ( Salvelinus namaycush ) diversity occur within the largest, deepest lakes of North America (i.e. > 2000 km 2 ). We report here Rush Lake (1.3 km 2 ) as the first example of a small lake with two lake charr morphs (lean and huronicus). Morphology, diet, life history, and genetics were examined to demonstrate the existence of morphs and determine the potential influence of evolutionary processes that led to their formation or maintenance. Results showed that the huronicus morph, caught in deep-water, had a deeper body, smaller head and jaws, higher eye position, greater buoyancy, and deeper peduncle than the shallow-water lean morph. Huronicus grew slower to a smaller adult size, and had an older mean age than the lean morph. Genetic comparisons showed low genetic divergence between morphs, indicating incomplete reproductive isolation. Phenotypic plasticity and differences in habitat use between deep and shallow waters associated with variation in foraging opportunities seems to have been sufficient to maintain the two morphs, demonstrating their important roles in resource polymorphism. Rush Lake expands previous explanations for lake charr intraspecific diversity, from large to small lakes and from reproductive isolation to the presence of gene flow associated with strong ecological drivers.

Explore related subjects

Biological Journal of the Linnean Society Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Louise Chavarie, Andrew M. Muir, Mara S. Zimmerman, Shauna M. Baillie, Michael J. Hansen, Nancy A. Nate, Daniel L. Yule, Trevor Middel, Paul Bentzen, Charles C. Krueger. 2016-11-16. Challenge to the model of lake charr evolution: Shallow- and deep-water morphs exist within a small postglacial lake. https://doi.org/10.1111/bij.12913

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2020

Influence of niche breadth and position on the historical biogeography of seafaring scincid lizards

Niche breadth and position can influence diversification among closely related species or populations, yet limited empirical data exist concerning the predictability of the outcomes. We explored the effects of these factors on the evolution of the Emoia atrocostata species group, an insular radiation of lizards in the western Pacific Ocean and Indo-Australasia composed of both endemic and widespread species that differ in niche occupancy. We used molecular data and phylogeographical diffusion models to estimate the timing and patterns of range expansion, and ancestral reconstruction methods to infer shifts in ecology. We show evidence of multidirectional spread from a centre of origin in western Micronesia, and that the phyletic diversity of the group is derived from a putative habitat specialist that survives in the littoral zone. This species is composed of paraphyletic lineages that represent stages or possible endpoints in the continuum toward speciation. Several descendant species have transitioned to either strand or interior forest habitat, but only on remote islands with depauperate terrestrial faunas. Our results suggest that the atrocostata group might be in the early phases of a Wilsonian taxon cycle and that the capacity to tolerate salt stress has promoted dispersal and colonization of remote oceanic islands. Divergence itself, however, is largely driven by geographical isolation rather than shifts in ecology.

Biological Journal of the Linnean Society↗

USGS2020

Genomic identification of intergeneric hybrids in New World wood-warblers (Aves: Parulidae)

The documentation of hybrids between distantly related taxa can illustrate an initial step to explain how genes might move between species that do not exhibit complete reproductive isolation. In birds, some of the most phylogenetically distant hybrid combinations occur between genera. Traditionally, morphological and plumage characters have been used to assign the identity of the parental species of a putative hybrid, although recently, nuclear introns also have been used. Here, we demonstrate how high-throughput short-read DNA sequence data can be used to identify the parentage of a putative intergeneric hybrid, in this case between a blue-winged warbler ( Vermivora cyanoptera ) and a cerulean warbler ( Setophaga cerulea ). This hybrid had mitochondrial DNA of a cerulean warbler, indicating the maternal parent. For hundreds of single nucleotide polymorphisms within six regions of the nuclear genome that differentiate blue-winged warblers and golden-winged warblers ( Vermivora chrysoptera ), the hybrid had roughly equal ancestry assignment to blue-winged and cerulean warblers, suggesting a blue-winged warbler as the paternal parent species and demonstrating that this was a first generation (F 1 ) hybrid between these species. Unlike other recently characterized intergeneric warbler hybrids, this individual hybrid learned to song match its maternal parent species, suggesting that it might have been the result of an extra-pair mating and raised in a cerulean warbler nest.

Biological Journal of the Linnean Society↗

USGS2018

Molecular and morphometric analyses reveal cryptic diversity within freshwater mussels (Bivalvia: Unionidae) of the western Gulf coastal drainages of the USA

Past geological processes and climate change affected current species distributions and the genetic structure of riverine fauna. Western Gulf of Mexico coastal rivers harbour four mussel species within the genus Fusconaia (Bivalvia: Unionida). The distributions of these species are unclear owing to their indistinguishable shell morphologies. Using molecular phylogenetic and Fourier morphometric analyses, we examined phylogenetic relationships and morphological variation among the species and made inferences about the role of past geological and climatic factors in shaping the current genetic structure and distributions of these species in the region. Our results showed the presence of three Fusconaia species within the region: Fusconaia askewi , Fusconaia chunii and Fusconaia flava . We confirmed that Fusconaia lananensis is a junior synonym of F. askewi and that F. chunii is genetically distinct from F. askewi . The Trinity River has syntopic F. flava whose morphologies are indistinguishable from those of F. chunii . Divergence-time estimates matched major geological and climatic events in the region, where climate-driven river formations during the mid-Miocene to Pleistocene caused major diversification of Fusconaia species. Knowledge gained from the present study provides a better understanding of vicariant events that shaped current species distributions and helps to identify conservation priorities that apply to the Fusconaia species.

Biological Journal of the Linnean Society↗