Mitigation effectiveness for improving nesting success of greater sage-grouse influenced by energy development

Christopher P. Kirol; Andrew L. Sutphin; Laura S. Bond; Mark R. Fuller; Thomas L. Maechtle

doi:10.2981/wlb.00002

Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70142075

Mitigation effectiveness for improving nesting success of greater sage-grouse influenced by energy development

Christopher P. Kirol·Andrew L. Sutphin·Laura S. Bond·Mark R. Fuller·Thomas L. Maechtle

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Sagebrush Artemisia spp. habitats being developed for oil and gas reserves are inhabited by sagebrush obligate species — including the greater sage-grouse Centrocercus urophasianus (sage-grouse) that is currently being considered for protection under the U.S. Endangered Species Act. Numerous studies suggest increasing oil and gas development may exacerbate species extinction risks. Therefore, there is a great need for effective on-site mitigation to reduce impacts to co-occurring wildlife such as sage-grouse. Nesting success is a primary factor in avian productivity and declines in nesting success are also thought to be an important contributor to population declines in sage-grouse. From 2008 to 2011 we monitored 296 nests of radio-marked female sage-grouse in a natural gas (NG) field in the Powder River Basin, Wyoming, USA, and compared nest survival in mitigated and non-mitigated development areas and relatively unaltered areas to determine if specific mitigation practices were enhancing nest survival. Nest survival was highest in relatively unaltered habitats followed by mitigated, and then non-mitigated NG areas. Reservoirs used for holding NG discharge water had the greatest support as having a direct relationship to nest survival. Within a 5-km 2 area surrounding a nest, the probability of nest failure increased by about 15% for every 1.5 km increase in reservoir water edge. Reducing reservoirs was a mitigation focus and sage-grouse nesting in mitigated areas were exposed to almost half of the amount of water edge compared to those in non-mitigated areas. Further, we found that an increase in sagebrush cover was positively related to nest survival. Consequently, mitigation efforts focused on reducing reservoir construction and reducing surface disturbance, especially when the surface disturbance results in sagebrush removal, are important to enhancing sage-grouse nesting success.

Explore related subjects

Wildlife Biology Article

Source-reported bounding extent: 43.44893105587766° to 44.5826428195842° latitude; -107.3583984375° to -105.97412109375° longitude. This indicates report coverage, not an exact sampling location. View area on OpenStreetMap.

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Christopher P. Kirol, Andrew L. Sutphin, Laura S. Bond, Mark R. Fuller, Thomas L. Maechtle. 2015. Mitigation effectiveness for improving nesting success of greater sage-grouse influenced by energy development. https://doi.org/10.2981/wlb.00002

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Life-history stages and behavior influence demographic classification of moose captured on remote cameras

Obtaining accurate information on demographic states, such as the age and sex classes of animals, is an important step for monitoring wildlife populations. Traditionally, demographic data are collected from harvest, aerial surveys and telemetry studies. However, these methods can be expensive, limited to small spatial scales, or biased due to human behavior. Remote cameras have become a mainstay for studying and monitoring wildlife as they are relatively inexpensive, can be deployed over large spatial scales, and effort can be accounted for during surveys. For some species, a variety of demographic information, such as sex and age classes, can be obtained from pictures. Moose Alces alces are a photogenic species found across boreal and semi-boreal forests of the Northern Hemisphere. Previous studies have used demographic data from remote cameras to estimate demographic parameters and population dynamics. A primary assumption is that these age and sex classes are accurately classified. However, numerous factors can influence the ability of observers to identify age and sex classes of moose captured on cameras. We used data from 84 cameras from a 3-year period (2021–2024) in northern Maine, USA, to evaluate how temporal, environmental, site-level, and endogenous factors influence observers' ability to classify age and sex classes of moose. Using Bayesian categorical regression models, we found that temporal variability, position and proximity of moose from cameras, and the behavior of moose influenced our ability to identify age and sex classes. This information can be used to decide which periods to use data for population modeling and how to design studies to reduce the amount of uncertainty associated with different age and sex classes. We anticipate that our approach could also be used for other species whose age and sex classes can be differentiated using remote cameras.

Maine↗

USGS2026

Biological and environmental drivers of early life fawn survival in a declining pronghorn population

Pronghorn Antilocapra americana occupy only a portion of their historical range and in Oklahoma occur at the eastern edge of the species' contemporary distribution. Monitoring has suggested pronghorn populations in Oklahoma have declined in recent years. We captured and collared 125 adult females across two winters, monitored them for signs of parturition during each subsequent spring, and then captured and radio-collared 70 fawns ≤ 4 days old. We assessed cause-specific mortality, estimated proportional survival, and visualized survival of fawns through 60 days of life with Kaplan–Meier curves. Nearly 87% of fawn mortalities were attributed to predation, with > 77% of predations attributed to coyotes Canis latrans . Our results indicated that fawn survival was lowest during the first 15 days of life, with 33% of fawns surviving to 15 days and 12% surviving to 60 days. We used known-fate models to evaluate the influence of biological factors (i.e. sex, mass, birth timing), environmental factors (i.e. ambient temperature, precipitation, vegetation), and temporal variation on the probability of early life (i.e. the first 15 days) survival. For each adult female with a collared fawn, we used female space-use patterns for 30 days before and 15 days after parturition to collect environmental covariates. Early life probability of survival was lower for larger fawns, those born earlier in the parturition period (i.e. earlier in the year relative to the range of parturition days), and those with higher pre-parturition temperatures; daily probability of survival decreased with time-since-parturition within the first 15 days of life. Our results indicate poor fawn survival, highlight a potential limitation of population growth, and can inform population management by identifying factors influencing early life fawn survival.

Oklahoma↗

USGS2026

Population trends of dabbling ducks wintering in the alluvial valleys of Arkansas and Mississippi

Population abundances, distributions, and compositions across a diversity of taxa are changing, partly as a consequence of human-induced global modifications. Although linking population fluctuations to anthropogenic-induced alterations can be challenging, it is increasingly clear that long-term monitoring is critical to understanding changing populations. For waterfowl, concerns over recent declines in breeding populations or possible redistribution from using traditional wintering grounds for some species support continued monitoring of regional populations. To further understand population trends on traditional wintering grounds, we examined abundance trends over time within the Mississippi and Arkansas portions of the Mississippi Alluvial Valley, using two sources of data: systematic aerial surveys and citizen science data. We found great annual variability in rates of population change ( r ranging from −1.04 to 0.71) in five species of dabbling ducks. Despite this annual variation, green-winged teal Anas carolinensis , mallards Anas platyrhynchos , northern pintail Anas acuta , and northern shoveler Spatula clypeata showed no significant trends in population size over approximately 15 years in Mississippi and Arkansas, but gadwall Mareca strepera showed a 4% annual increase in the citizen science data for Mississippi. Despite substantial variation in annual abundance, the timing of peak abundance was remarkably consistent from year to year, with peaks typically occurring in January. Our results demonstrate that autumn–winter population numbers of dabbling ducks can be quite variable interannually, but they lack a consistent trend in the Mississippi Alluvial Valley during the past two decades. Going forward, investigation into how citizen science data could be leveraged to increase the precision of trends within this landscape might be of benefit, and sampling efforts could perhaps be added towards the latter portion of the wintering period. As populations continue to adjust in a changing world, maintaining monitoring surveys in regions important to waterfowl is an effective and important means of evaluating trends.

Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississip↗