Search USGS⌕ Search
Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70034597

Contain or eradicate? Optimizing the management goal for Australian acacia invasions in the face of uncertainty

J.L. Moore·M.C. Runge·B.L. Webber·J.R.U. Wilson
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Aim To identify whether eradication or containment is expected to be the most cost‐effective management goal for an isolated invasive population when knowledge about the current extent is uncertain. Location Global and South Africa. Methods We developed a decision analysis framework to analyse the best management goal for an invasive species population (eradication, containment or take no action) when knowledge about the current extent is uncertain. We used value of information analysis to identify when investment in learning about the extent will improve this decision‐making and tested the sensitivity of the conclusions to different parameters (e.g. spread rate, maximum extent, and management efficacy and cost). The model was applied to Acacia paradoxa DC, an Australian shrub with an estimated invasive extent of 310 ha on Table Mountain, South Africa. Results Under the parameters used, attempting eradication is cost‐effective for infestations of up to 777 ha. However, if the invasion extent is poorly known, then attempting eradication is only cost‐effective for infestations estimated as 296 ha or smaller. The value of learning is greatest (maximum of 8% saving) when infestation extent is poorly known and if it is close to the maximum extent for which attempting eradication is optimal. The optimal management action is most sensitive to the probability that the action succeeds (which depends on the extent), with the discount rate and cost of management also important, but spread rate less so. Over a 20‐year time‐horizon, attempting to eradicate A. paradoxa from South Africa is predicted to cost on average ZAR 8 million if the extent is known, and if our current estimate is poor, ZAR 33.6 million as opposed to ZAR 32.8 million for attempting containment. Main conclusions Our framework evaluates the cost‐effectiveness of attempting eradication or containment of an invasive population that takes uncertainty in population extent into account. We show that incorporating uncertainty in the analysis avoids overly optimistic beliefs about the effectiveness of management enabling better management decisions. For A. paradoxa in South Africa, attempting to eradicate is likely to be cost‐effective, particularly if resources are allocated to better understand and improve management efficacy

Explore related subjects

Diversity and DistributionsArticle

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

J.L. Moore, M.C. Runge, B.L. Webber, J.R.U. Wilson. 2011-08-08. Contain or eradicate? Optimizing the management goal for Australian acacia invasions in the face of uncertainty. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1472-4642.2011.00809.x

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Null models reveal differing drivers of multidimensional beta diversity change in invaded metacommunities

Aim Invasion-driven changes in beta diversity (Δβ) are multifaceted (taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic) and are comprised of three components (total beta diversity, replacement, and richness difference); therefore, they represent a nine-dimensional phenomenon. Invasion-driven trajectories of multidimensional Δβ are inconsistent and can vary based on the geographic origin of nonnative species, native community structure, and site attributes. Here, we examine the drivers of multidimensional Δβ to better understand how nonnative species alter biodiversity. Location 1023 wadable-stream fish communities across the conterminous United States. Methods We characterized nine dimensions of Δβ as changes in local contribution to beta diversity (ΔLCBD) derived from pairwise beta diversity of all 1023 sites between contemporary and native-only assemblages at each site. We used redundancy analysis and variance partitioning to identify and estimate the relative importance of 18 Δβ drivers related to nonnative species origin, propagule pressure, abiotic factors, and native community structure. We compared results between those from raw and null model standardized LCBD. Results We found an overall trend of taxonomic homogenization due to nonnative species occurrences. However, null model standardization revealed inconsistent directional change in functional and phylogenetic Δβ, and also revealed Δβ patterns and drivers that differed from those of raw values. Sites did not contribute evenly to overall Δβ trends, with nonnative species origin and native community structure explaining the most variation in ΔLCBD (16% and 15% respectively). Nonnative occurrences, regardless of origin, contributed to taxonomic homogenization, with the magnitude of change dependent on origin. Native community structure dictated the direction of phylogenetic Δβ, with phylogenetically distinct sites contributing to homogenization. Conclusions Our findings demonstrate the utility in using LCBD to identify site-level drivers of Δβ and the need for null model standardization of multidimensional Δβ metrics. Additionally, our results show that spatially explicit definitions of nonnative species are needed to gain robust estimates of Δβ.

conterminous United States↗
USGS2026

Predicted range shifts of non‐native grasses in response to climate change are influenced by photosynthetic pathway: A case study in the Hawaiian Islands

Aim Grasses comprise three main photosynthetic pathway variants (C 3 -BOP, C 3 -PACMAD and C 4 -PACMAD hereafter referred to as C 4 ). We sought to confirm climate niche differences among these photosynthetic pathway variants and assessed whether predicted non-native grass range shift patterns with climate change differ among photosynthetic pathway variants. Location Hawaiian Islands. Methods We used a species distribution modelling (SDM) approach that uses global occurrence records to inform local SDM based on local (Hawaiian Islands) occurrences. We compared climate niches and projected climate-driven range shifts, assuming moderate climate change (RCP 4.5, end of century), among 22 non-native grasses representing C 3 -BOP, C 3 -PACMAD and C 4 photosynthetic pathway variants. Results C 4 grasses exhibited the warmest temperature niches on average, but did not differ substantially in rainfall niche versus C 3 -BOP grasses. C 3 -PACMAD species averaged high suitability across a broad range of temperatures and rainfall conditions, except extreme aridity. In response to projected climate change, C 4 grasses had projected range increases. C 3 -BOP grasses typically responded with net range decreases, while C 3 -PACMAD grasses had variable range responses. However, patterns were contingent on elevation: for instance, the projected expansion of C 4 grasses was generally limited to elevations below 2000 m, with the largest increases in areas up to ~750 m. Areas of greatest reduction for C 3 -BOP and C 3 -PACMAD were projected at 750–1900 m and 100–1100 m elevation, respectively. Above 2000 m, range increases were projected for both C 3 grass variants. Main Conclusions Our projections suggest that non-native C 4 grasses pose the greatest risk for increasing spread and impacts under RCP 4.5, while certain C 3 -PACMAD grasses may endanger valuable high-elevation habitats. Photosynthetic pathway may be a useful component of weed risk assessment to evaluate how species may respond to climate change as similar range response patterns may be expected for other non-native grasses in other tropical and subtropical regions.

Hawaii↗
USGS2026

Changes in spatial distribution and abundance together determine potential for population persistence for greater sage-grouse

Aim Population ecologists often focus on changes in the distribution and abundance of wildlife species, which are useful for trend analyses and status assessments. However, rarely are these responses evaluated simultaneously for a single species, despite their unique contributions to fully assess a species' viability. For example, focusing solely on total abundance can mask important losses in overall distribution within a metapopulation structure that may contribute to long-term population instability that results from the extirpation of small peripheral populations. Location Bi-State region of Nevada and California, USA. Methods We simultaneously evaluated changes in population abundance and distribution for greater sage-grouse (hereafter sage-grouse; Centrocercus urophasianus ) within the Bi-State Distinct Population Segment (DPS), a genetically distinct and isolated population straddling the border of Nevada and California. We combined population counts, demographic data, and information on space use from marked individuals to evaluate changes in population distribution and abundance over three time periods that corresponded to the three most recent population nadirs (1995–2019, 2002–2019 and 2008–2019). Results The Bi-State DPS exhibited evidence of ~1.2%–2.5% declines annually, over the short/medium-term (1995–2019; λ^ = 0.987, 95% CRI: 0.970–0.999), short-term (2002–2019; λ^ = 0.975, 95% CRI: 0.963–0.985) and recent-term (2008–2019; λ^ = 0.988, 95% CRI: 0.973–1.001). Since 1995, the spatial distribution of sage-grouse abundance in the Bi-State DPS shifted amongst subpopulations, with peripheral subpopulations suffering the largest declines. Main Conclusions Gains in abundance and distribution amongst expanding subpopulations did not offset losses in the remaining subpopulations, with a net loss in occupied distribution of 156 km 2 since 1995. Reductions in spatial distribution could have implications for metapopulation persistence as peripheral populations become more vulnerable to stochastic events, which would not have been apparent from the evaluation of overall metapopulation abundance on its own.

California, Nevada↗