Search USGS⌕ Search
Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 5224348

The relationship between species detection probability and local extinction probability

R. Alpizar-Jara·J.D. Nichols·J.E. Hines·J.R. Sauer·K. H. Pollock·C.S. Rosenberry
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

In community-level ecological studies, generally not all species present in sampled areas are detected. Many authors have proposed the use of estimation methods that allow detection probabilities that are < 1 and that are heterogeneous among species. These methods can also be used to estimate community-dynamic parameters such as species local extinction probability and turnover rates (Nichols et al. Ecol Appl 8:1213-1225; Conserv Biol 12:1390-1398). Here, we present an ad hoc approach to estimating community-level vital rates in the presence of joint heterogeneity of detection probabilities and vital rates. The method consists of partitioning the number of species into two groups using the detection frequencies and then estimating vital rates (e.g., local extinction probabilities) for each group. Estimators from each group are combined in a weighted estimator of vital rates that accounts for the effect of heterogeneity. Using data from the North American Breeding Bird Survey, we computed such estimates and tested the hypothesis that detection probabilities and local extinction probabilities were negatively related. Our analyses support the hypothesis that species detection probability covaries negatively with local probability of extinction and turnover rates. A simulation study was conducted to assess the performance of vital parameter estimators as well as other estimators relevant to questions about heterogeneity, such as coefficient of variation of detection probabilities and proportion of species in each group. Both the weighted estimator suggested in this paper and the original unweighted estimator for local extinction probability performed fairly well and provided no basis for preferring one to the other.

Explore related subjects

OecologiaArticle

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

R. Alpizar-Jara, J.D. Nichols, J.E. Hines, J.R. Sauer, K. H. Pollock, C.S. Rosenberry. 2004-09-15. The relationship between species detection probability and local extinction probability. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-004-1641-0

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Selective mortality leads to competitive release of a foundational perennial grass in an aridifying grassland

Vegetation dynamics in dryland ecosystems are defined by competition for water, a limiting and increasingly variable resource. As aridification creates warmer and drier conditions, with more frequent and intense droughts, the nature of competitive relationships may be altered, leading to changes in community composition. Reduced water availability is expected to decrease the cover and abundance of cool-season C 3 grasses on the Colorado Plateau, with unknown impacts on other plant functional types, such as drought-tolerant C 4 species. Here, we explore the effects of competitive release on Pleuraphis jamesii , a dominant C 4 grass with rooting and photosynthetic traits that may enable it to capitalize on the mortality of less drought tolerant C 3 species. To accomplish this, we used herbicide to create three removal treatments (C 3 grass and forb removal, C 4 grass removal, and control (no removal)) surrounding P. jamesii focal individuals and measured the subsequent impacts on water availability and plant water relations and growth. The experimentally induced mortality resulted in greater water availability for focal individuals in the C 3 removal treatment. Increased water availability in C 3 removal plots translated to less water stress and greater biomass production of focal P. jamesii plants, suggesting that competitive release can serve as the basis for shifts in community composition towards drought tolerant C 4 plants observed regionally. These responses were not observed in the C 4 removal treatment despite removing roughly equivalent amounts of total plant cover. Our results suggest that reductions in C 3 competitors may benefit drought-tolerant C 4 species through increased resource availability. These findings contribute to a mechanistic understanding of competitive interactions in increasingly water-limited systems.

Utah↗
USGS2026

Carryover effects across juvenile periods vary by species, cause-specific mortality, and stage-specific behavior

Conditions during one life-stage can carry over to influence fitness outcomes in later stages. How carryover effects manifest, however, may vary depending on the type and magnitude of risks that animals face in subsequent life-stages. The influence of carryover effects on cause-specific mortality remains largely unclear, particularly during vulnerable life-stages, including juvenile periods. We proposed and investigated the Cause-specific carryover hypothesis, that the relative influence of traits developed during a previous stage on mortality during the next vary by cause of mortality, using juvenile sagebrush songbirds (Brewer’s sparrow, Spizella breweri ; sagebrush sparrow, Artemisiospiza nevadensis ; sage thrasher, Oreoscoptes montanus ) as a focal system. We tracked birds during the post-fledging period (a juvenile period following the nestling period), identified the rates and causes of mortality, and tested the relative influence of different nestling traits (wing length, tarsus length, feather development, and body condition) on post-fledging mortality risk. Carryover effects varied across co-occurring species and differed by cause of mortality, and tarsus length had an unexpected and outsized impact on predation risk in the two sparrows. Although wing morphology typically is considered the most important trait for mobility in birds, most mortalities occurred during the first 5 days of the post-fledging period when altricial fledglings were incapable of flight and likely relied on running or scrambling ability to escape predators. Therefore, carryover effects were driven by stage-specific behavior during the period of highest risk. Developing animals may face investment trade-offs between morphological traits that influence different types of risk during different subsequent stages.

Wyoming↗
USGS2026

The functional effects of African lions on co-occurring carnivores differ across species pairs and with changes in resource availability and lion abundance

Apex carnivores are known to regulate ecosystem structure and function, including via interactions with syntopic, competitively inferior carnivores. These effects may be dependent on relative carnivore density and resource availability or productivity. We investigated the functional effect of African lions as an apex carnivore on the presence of co-occurring large carnivore species across two adjoining National Parks that contrast in relative densities of carnivores and prey. We employed two-species occupancy models from track data to test statistical interactions between lions and the other syntopic large carnivore species, while accounting for each species’ habitat selection. We further investigated the influence of anthropogenic and natural variables on these co-occurrence dynamics. Our models revealed that the occurrence of each carnivore species was best predicted by access to their own key resources. We also found significant statistical interactions between lions and cheetahs, lions and leopards, and lions and spotted hyenas in resource-rich landscapes. Finally, we found limited support for the competition exclusion hypothesis between most species, with the exception of lion-African wild dog co-occurrence patterns. Species’ co-occurrence dynamics were all influenced by resource availability, with lion-leopard and lion-cheetah co-occurrence decreasing strongly with increasing resource availability. Most species co-occurrence declined with increasing occurrence of lions. The patterns revealed by this study improves predictions of how changes in resource availability and carnivore occurrence could impact carnivore community dynamics and the functional role of apex carnivores.

Kruger National Park, Limpopo National Park↗